C. Experts

	This page lists 205 paintings that are (or once were) attributed to Caravaggio with an aim to record who published the attibution first. The list is grouped by [HIERARCHY] {Click buttons on the left to change grouping} The frame colour describes how the painting is accepted today


Autograph paintings (the majority accept these paintings as by Caravaggio)	1821 Giuseppe Grosso Cacopardo Adoration of the Shepherds Museo Regionale Messina 1906 Sacca Nativity with Saints Lawrence and Francis Oratory Of The Compagnia Di San Lorenzo (formerly) Palermo 1924 Hermann Voss Agony in the Garden Kaiser Friedrich Museum (formerly) Berlin 1948 Pariset Annunciation Musee Des Beaux-arts Nancy 1927 Roberto Longhi Bacchus Galleria Borghese Rome 1922 Matteo Marangoni Bacchus Galleria Degli Uffizi Florence 1920 RouchÃ©s Burial of Saint Lucy Church of Saint Lucia al Sepolcro Syracuse 1928 Roberto Longhi The Cardsharps Kimbell Art Museum Fort Worth 1971 Luigi Salerno Conversion of Mary Magdalen Detroit Institute Of Arts Detroit 1884 Burckhardt Conversion of Saint Paul Private Collection (Odescalchi) 1913 Roberto Longhi Conversion of Saint Paul Cerasi Chapel Santa Maria Del Popolo Rome 1974 Maurizio Marini Crowning with Thorns Kunsthistorisches Museum Vienna 1974 Benedict Nicolson Crucifixion of Saint Andrew Cleveland Museum Of Art Ohio 1913 Roberto Longhi Crucifixion of Saint Peter Cerasi Chapel Santa Maria Del Popolo Rome 1915 Roberto Longhi Sleeping Cupid Palazzo Pitti Florence 1833 Ancient Inventories David with the Head of Goliath Galleria Borghese Rome 1730 Ancient Inventories (Galerie du Palais Royal Paris) Death of the Virgin Louvre Paris 1812 Delaroche The Incredulity of St Thomas Shiftung Schlosser Und Garten Sanssouci Potsdam 1912 Lionello Venturi Supper at Emmaus Pinacoteca Di Brera Milan 1906 Kallab Supper at Emmaus National Gallery London 1820 Craffonara Entombment Pinacoteca Vaticana Rome 1826 Ancient Inventories Portrait of Fillide Kaiser Friedrich Museum (formerly) Berlin 1928 Matteo Marangoni Saint Catherine of Alexandria Thyssen Bornemisza Museum Madrid 1815 Romanelli Flagellation of Christ Museo Nazionale Di Capodimonte Naples 1960 Roberto Longhi Flagellation of Christ Musee Des Beaux-arts Rouen 1924 Hermann Voss Fortune Teller (Buona Ventura) Pinacoteca Capitolina Rome 1924 Hermann Voss Fortune Teller (Buona Ventura) Louvre Paris 1951 Denis Mahon Saint Francis in Prayer Pinacoteca Del Museo Civico Cremona 1929 Matteo Marangoni Saint Francis in Ecstasy Wadsworth Atheneum Hartford Connecticut 1925 Borenius Boy Bitten by a Lizard National Gallery London 1990 Calvesi Boy Bitten by a Lizard Longhi Foundation Florence 1790 Ancient Inventories Boy with a Basket of Fruit Galleria Borghese Rome 1924 Hermann Voss Sacrifice of Isaac Galleria Degli Uffizi Florence 1909 Modigliani in Venturi Saint Jerome Galleria Borghese Rome 1922 Matteo Marangoni Saint Jerome Saint John's Co Cathedral Valletta 1920 RouchÃ©s Beheading of Saint John the Baptist Saint John's Co Cathedral Valletta 1893 Lionello Venturi Saint John the Baptist Galleria Borghese Rome 1927 Roberto Longhi Saint John the Baptist Palazzo Barberini Rome 1943 Roberto Longhi Saint John the Baptist Nelson- Atkins Museum Of Art Kansas City 1953 Denis Mahon Saint John the Baptist Pinacoteca Capitolina Rome 1951 Roberto Longhi Judith Beheading Holofernes Palazzo Barberini Rome 1790 Ancient Inventories Madonna dei Palafrenieri Galleria Borghese Rome 1906 Kallab Madonna of Loreto Cavalletti Chapel Sant' Agostino Rome 1786 Ancient Inventories Madonna of the Rosary Kunsthistorisches Museum Vienna 1906 Kallab Penitent Magdalen Galleria Doria Pamphili Rome 1974 Mina Gregori {Roberto} Martyrdom of Saint Ursula Palazzo Zevallos Collezione Banca Intesa Naples 1855 Burckhardt Calling of Saint Matthew Contarelli Chapel San Luigi Dei Francesi Rome 1812 Landon Saint Matthew and the Angel Kaiser Friedrich Museum (formerly) Berlin 1922 Matteo Marangoni Saint Matthew and the Angel Contarelli Chapel San Luigi Dei Francesi Rome 1855 Burckhardt Martyrdom of Saint Matthew Contarelli Chapel San Luigi Dei Francesi Rome 1910 Lionello Venturi The Luteplayer Hermitage Saint Petersburg 1952 Denis Mahon Musicians Metropolitan Museum Of Art New York 1969 Giuliana Zandri Jupiter Neptune and Pluto Villa Boncompagni-ludovisi Rome 1819 Ancient Inventories Medusa Galleria Degli Uffizi Florence 1970 Roberto Longhi Denial of Saint Peter Metropolitan Museum Of Art New York 1974 Mina Gregori {Roberto} Portrait of a Knight of Malta Palazzo Pitti Florence 1730 Ancient Inventories (Galerie du Palais Royal Paris) Portrait of Alof de Wignacourt and a Page Louvre Paris 1840 La Farina Raising of Lazarus Museo Regionale Messina 1872 Meyer Rest on the flight to Egypt Galleria Doria Pamphili Rome 1959 Roberto Longhi Salome with the Head of Saint John the Baptist National Gallery London 1927 Roberto Longhi Salome with the Head of Saint John the Baptist Palacio Real Madrid 1902 Ruggiero Seven Acts of Mercy Pio Monte Della Misericordia Naples 1907 Ratti Still Life with a Basket of Fruit Pinacoteca Ambrosiana Milan 1812 Delaroche Victorious Cupid (Amor Vincit Omnia) Staatliche Museen Berlin
64
Several experts agree	1924 Hermann Voss Calling of Saints Peter and Andrew Royal Collection Hampton Court Palace 1961 Jullian Crowning with Thorns Cassa Di Risparmio E Depositi Prato Florence 1924 Hermann Voss David with the Head of Goliath Kunsthistorisches Museum Vienna 1927 Lionello Venturi David and Goliath Museo Nacional Del Prado Madrid 2004 Petrucci Maddalena Addolorata Private Collection 2021 Massimo Pulini Ecce Homo in front of pilate Madrid 1954 Roberto Longhi Ecce Homo Civica Galleria Di Palazzo Rosso Genoa 1908 Cantalmessa Saint Francis in Meditation Santa Maria della Concezione (Church of the Cappuc Rome 1908 Cantalmessa Saint Francis in Meditation Palazzo Barberini Rome 1982 Maurizio Marini Boy Peeling Fruit Private Collection 1943 Roberto Longhi Saint Jerome in Meditation Pinacoteca Monastery Of Santa Maria Di Montserrat Barcelona 1971 Rottgen Vision of Saint Jerome Worcester Art Museum Mass 1951 Roberto Longhi Saint John the Baptist at the Source MUZA _National Museum of Art Valletta 1969 Amadore Porcella Saint John the Baptist at the Source Private Collection 1964 Pérez Sánchez Saint John the Baptist Cathedral Museum Toledo 1974 Pérez Sánchez Saint John the Baptist Reclining Private Collection Munich 2016 Roberta Lapucci San Giovannino giacente (Saint John the Baptist Reclining) private collection 2019 Eric Turquin Judith Beheading Holofernes Toulouse 1951 Roberto Longhi Holy Family with St. John the Baptist Clara Otero Silva Collection, Caracas Venezuela 1972 Pico Cellini Magdalen in Ecstasy Private Collection 2014 Mina Gregori {Roberto} Magdalen in Ecstasy 2003 Clovis Whitfield The Luteplayer Private Collection 1914 Roberto Longhi Narcissus Palazzo Barberini Rome 1921 Mariano Luigi Patrizi Portrait of Monsignor Maffeo Barberini Corsini Florence 1963 Roberto Longhi Portrait of Monsignor Maffeo Barberini Private Collection 1906 Kallab Portrait of Paul V Borghese Prince Camillo Borghese Rome 1979 Benedict Nicolson Saint Sebastian Private Collection 1993 Sergio Benedetti Taking of Christ National Gallery Of Ireland Dublin 1975 Mina Gregori {Roberto} The Toothpuller Palazzo Pitti Florence 2010 Alessandro Zuccari Boy Bitten by a Lizard Private Collection Rome
30
Few experts agree (perhaps because few have studied these painting)	2008 Roberta Lapucci Martyrdom of Saint Catherine Parish Church Zejtun 1954 Hermann Voss Crucifixion of Saint Andrew Private Collection [Beck-Vega] 2018 Roberta Lapucci Cupid and the Skeleton Cathedral Museum Mdina 2004 Paolo Sapori Ecce Homo Private Collection 1969 Kitson Boy Peeling Fruit Ishizuka collection Tokyo 1996 John T. Spike Boy Peeling Fruit Private Collection Dickinson 2007 Roberta Lapucci Saint Jerome Private Collection 2010 Sebastian Schütze Sant Agostino Private Collection 2014 Roberta Lapucci THE SCHONBORN CORYDON 1990 Keith Christiansen The Luteplayer Metropolitan Museum Of Art (formerly) 2001 Maurizio Marini Medusa Private Collection 1912 Pieraccini Portrait of Cardinal Cesare Baronio (Sora 15381607 Rome) Galleria Degli Uffizi Florence 1993 Mina Gregori {Roberto} Portrait of a Gentleman Private Collection 2011 Massimo Pulini Portrait of Scipione Borghese Museo Civico Montepulciano 2001 Maurizio Marini Vase of Flowers Private Collection 1976 Federico Zeri Still Life with Birds Galleria Borghese Rome 1976 Federico Zeri Still-Life with Flowers and Fruit Galleria Borghese Rome 2005 Denis Mahon Taking of Christ Galleria Bigetti Rome 2023 Barbara Savina Taking of Christ private collection 1991 Mina Gregori {Roberto} Sacrifice of Isaac Barbara Piasecka Johnson Collection Princeton 1730 Ancient Inventories (Galerie du Palais Royal Paris) Philosopher Looking in a Mirror Private Collection 2001 Maurizio Marini Portrait of a Giovanni Battista Marino Private Collection 1927 Hermann Voss Lady with a gold chain San Diego Museum Of Art San Diego 1954 Swarzenski Still Life Museum of Fine Arts Boston 1995 John T. Spike Still Life with Fruit on a Stone Ledge Denver Art Museum Denver 2005 Denis Mahon The cardsharps The Museum of the Order of St John London 2001 Maurizio Marini Sleeping Cupid Museum of Art Indianapolis 1989 Maurizio Marini Ecce Homo S.F.Cortez Collection New York 1990 Gianni Papi Ecce Homo Madonna Arenzano 2010 Gianni Papi Ecce Homo 2001 Maurizio Marini Supper at Emmaus Private Collection 1974 Maurizio Marini Flagellation of Christ Palazzo Camuccini Cantalupo Sabina 1990 Ferdinando Bolonga Saint Francis of Assisi in Ecstasy Barbara Piasecka Johnson Collection Princeton 1951 Federico Zeri St John with a lamb Private Collection 1987 Maurizio Marini The Luteplayer Private Collection Salini 1974 Rottgen Denial of Saint Peter Metropolitan Museum Of Art New York 2016 Franco Moro Alessandro Alberti with a Page National Gallery Washington dc 2001 Maurizio Marini Sant Agapito Chiesa Di Sant Antonio Abate (palestrina) Rome 1992 Ferdinando Bolonga Salome with the Head of Saint John the Baptist Private Collection 1975 Federico Zeri Susanna and the Elders Koelliker Collection Milan
40
Engraving of Presumed lost original	1705 Ancient Inventories (Aix en Provence) Jacob dit a Laban visites tous vos troupeaux 1705 Ancient Inventories (Aix en Provence) Encounter of Jacob and Rachel 1754 Ancient Inventories Ecce Homo 1730 Ancient Inventories (Galerie du Palais Royal Paris) Sacrifice of Isaac Galerie du Palais Royal (formerly) Paris 1700 Ancient Inventories Mary Magdalen in the Desert Bibliotheca Hertziana Rome 1730 Ancient Inventories (Galerie du Palais Royal Paris) The Flute Player Engraving 1786 Galerie du Palais Royal (formerly) Paris 1705 Ancient Inventories (Aix en Provence) Vase of flowers after Caravaggio
7
Past Attributed that are no longer accepted	1705 Ancient Inventories (Aix en Provence) Jacob asking Labano for Rachel's Hand in Marriage Musee Granet Aix en Provence 1910 Breck Bacchus Staedelsches Kunstinstitut Frankfurt 1951 Bernard Berenson Card players Fogg Harvard Art Museum Massachusetts 1800 Ancient Inventories Christ disputing with the Doctors National Gallery Of Ireland Dublin 1950 Ancient Inventories Christ disputing with the Doctors Chiesa di San Martin Langres 1952 Roberto Longhi The Road to Calvary Kunsthistorisches Museum Vienna 1666 Inventario del Casino di San Marco Tribute Money Galleria Degli Uffizi Florence 1801 Christie\'s The Locksmith Dulwich Picture Gallery London 1850 Ancient Inventories Giuoco alla Morra Pinacoteca Nazionale Siena 1921 Ancient Inventories Cook in the Kitchen Corsini Florence 1936 Ancient Inventories The Fruit Vendor Detroit Institute Of Arts Detroit 1792 Vasi Girl with compass (Allegory of Astronomy) Spada Rome 1912 Lionello Venturi Tobias and the Angel Chiesa di S. Rufo Rieti 1855 Ancient Inventories Saint Gregory the Great Palazzo Barberini Rome 1921 Mariano Luigi Patrizi Saint Catherine of Alexandria Recanati 1920 RouchÃ©s Denial of Saint Peter Pinacoteca Vaticana Rome 1790 Ancient Inventories Mendicante Galleria Borghese Rome 1974 Ancient Inventories Esopo Golcher Foundation Mdina 1817 Ancient Inventories Vanitas Palazzo Barberini Rome 1833 Ancient Inventories Portrait of Marcello Provenzal Galleria Borghese Rome 1910 Herman H. Gram Portrait of a Gentleman Statens Museum of Kunst Copenhagen 1927 Hermann Voss Portrait of Lady with peach and jasmine in a vase Private Collection 1900 Ancient Inventories The Conversion of the Maltese Church St Paul's Bay 1980 Maurizio Marini Saint Rocco Private Collection 1980 Maurizio Marini Saint Sebastian Private Collection 1921 Mariano Luigi Patrizi Self Portait Private Collection 1928 Roberto Longhi Still Life with Fruit and Carafe National Gallery Washington dc 1973 Maurizio Marini Christ and the adultrous woman Private Collection 2001 Maurizio Marini Christ healing the sick Private Collection 1808 Ancient Catalogue (Museum ) Crucifixion of Saint Peter Hermitage Saint Petersburg 1920 Lionello Venturi Saint John with flowers and a Lamb Offentliche Kunstsammlung Basel 1906 Burckhardt The Theorbo Player Galleria Sabauda Torino 1920 Roberto Longhi Boy Playing Guitar bayerische Staatsgemaldesammlungen Munich 1912 Lionello Venturi I Santi Quattro Coronati Chiesa di S.S. Andrea e Leonardo a Tor de Specehi Rome 1921 Mariano Luigi Patrizi San Nicola E il Mendico Pinacoteca Podesti ancona 1921 Mariano Luigi Patrizi Saint Sebastian and St Irene M. Campori Modena 1921 Mariano Luigi Patrizi Self Portait Szepmuveszeti Museum Budapest 1952 Sterling Fruits and flowers Wadsworth Atheneum Hartford Connecticut
38
Presumed Copy of lost original	2001 Maurizio Marini Circumcision of Christ Santa Maria della Sanita Naples 2001 Maurizio Marini Il Beato Isidoro Agricola Pinacoteca Comunale Ascoli Piceno 2001 Maurizio Marini Divine Love Private Collection
3
Follower of Caravaggio	1792 Vasi Saint Ann and Mary Spada Rome 1817 MANAZZALE Madonna and Child Corsini Rome 1950 Ancient Inventories Saint Mary Magdalen private collection 1863 Brogi Penitent Magdalen Museo Civico Montepulciano 1922 Matteo Marangoni The Concert Galleria Degli Uffizi Florence 1907 Ancient Inventories Fight over cards Statens Museum of Kunst Copenhagen 1910 Barbier David with the Head of Goliath Spada Rome 1943 Roberto Longhi Supper at Emmaus Museo Regionale Messina 1892 Ancient Inventories Fortune-teller (buona ventura) Palazzo Barberini Rome 1922 Kallab The Luteplayer National Gallery Washington dc 1960 Luigi Salerno Portrait of a Gentleman (Sigismund Laire?) Staatliche Museen Berlin 1910 Lionello Venturi Saint John Evangelist Spada Rome 1976 Federico Zeri Asparagus still life 1976 Federico Zeri Still Lifes with carafes of Water Galleria Estense Modena 1976 Federico Zeri Still Lifes with carafes of Water Galleria Estense Modena 1976 Federico Zeri Two girls catching butterflies 1968 Ferdinando Bolonga A Still Life with Grapes Honey-Mellon Fruit Flowers and Butterflies Lingenauber Collection 1976 Federico Zeri A Still Life with Fruit Flower and Butterflies Lingenauber Collection 1937 Sestieri Cupid Chastised Institute Of Arts Chicago
19
Copy	Roberto Longhi Boy Peeling Fruit Longhi Foundation Florence 2004 Maurizio Marini David and Goliath Private Collection 1968 Roberto Longhi Saint John the Baptist Galleria Doria Pamphili Rome 2023 Vittorio Sgarbi Magdalena Sgarbi private collection

Add/Edit Comment